Reconstruction of a Fatal Accidental Shooting

Jun 06, 2016

A 20-year-old man was ordered to stand trial for murder in connection with the December 8, 2014 shooting death of his mother at their home near Lake Berryessa in Napa County, California.
Joseph Brooks Conkright, known as Brooks, told authorities that he accidentally shot Danae Dee Conkright, 54, while cleaning his rifle in the family’s living room. If found guilty Brooks could be sent to prison for life.

The Challenge for this case is how to use the physical evidence captured at the scene of a fatal shooting to determine the shooter’s position relative to the victim and the victim’s positioning at key moments during the event and at the point of rest. Further, to reconstruct the event with sufficient fidelity to the forensic evidence to successfully have the resulting 3D animation admitted at trial. PSI was asked by the young man’s defense team to review and analyze the available data to determine whether the defendant’s statements regarding the event are supported by the physical evidence.

The solution was to develop a 3D Working Model based upon laser scan data of the environment, 3D gunshot wound model based upon the medical examiner’s report and compare them to the statements given by Brooks describing the event as an accidental discharge of his firearm. Then, if the statements are supported by the evidence, create a compelling 3D animation to illustrate the findings for the jury at Brooks’ murder trial.

In order to complete the analysis, PSI reviewed specific documents and performed specific tasks. The documents most critical of these were the following:

  • Recorded Police Detective interview of Brooks.
  • Drawings created by Police Detective during interview with Brooks.
  • California Department of Justice Physical Evidence Examination Report.
  • Serological Research Institute Analytical Report.
  • First 911 call initiated by Brooks.
  • Second 911 call initiated by Brook’s Father.
  • Incident Scene Photography.
  • Napa County Sheriff Coroner’s Report.
  • Autopsy Report.
  • Napa County Sheriff Supplemental Reports.
  • Napa County Sheriff scene measurements and diagram.

After a single day of deliberation, the jury acquitted the defendant Joseph Brooks Conkright of murder, referencing the PSI analysis and visualization as critical in coming to their verdict.

Click Here To Read Entire Case Study

Click Below to View a Composite Animation Used in Trial




Category:

Craig Fries

user_avatar

Craig Fries is the Founder and President of Precision Simulations, Inc., the foremost forensic analysis and animation firm in the US. In this role he has created or directed over 1,000 3D forensic animations for use in criminal and civil litigation and has maintained a 100% record of non-exclusion at trial. As a pioneer in the field of forensic laser scanning, Craig created the first 3D animation based upon laser scan data ever admitted at trial in the US, and has been at the forefront of the use of the technology in homicide and accident investigation since.


Add Pingback

Please add a comment

You must be logged in to leave a reply. Login »

Tag Cloud

Driver's Eye View ObstructionWitness StandCACSurgical Animationaccident reconstructionNieto VerdictCamera Lense Distortionlargest infant death settlement in californiaCalifornia Association of Crime Lab DirectorsISO 17020Trajectory3D Working Model$84,000,000 VerdictsCriminalistFEWA Secretary3D Animation over Nighttime VideoDr Judy MelinekOperator Liabilitysacramento settlementMeasurementsCraig FriesBallistics Analysisreconstruction analysisRay Tensingevidence documentationCA2RS2014 Annual ConferenceAnimation over Video402 HearingTImeline from AudioOld Way vs Best WayAR15Visible GeometryDemonstrative ExhibitsforensicRadio TrafficSurgicalEmergency Deployment RecordersThe Working ModelTrace Back Analysisinfant death settlementscientific evidence911 CallAnalysisVideo Analysisdepositionbody camera for deputies and officersShadow AnalysisCalifornia Association of CriminalistsCrosswalk in ShadowExcellent PresentationsCalifornia Association of Accident Reconstruction SpecialistsSouth Lake TahoeMuni Bus On-Board Camera Systemforensic expertFirst Degree MurderLitigationPhotogrammetryTestimony.223Complex Accident Scene Reconstructionnighttime visibility studyExpert's PreparationTiming and Location of EvidencecollaborativeCACLDProfessional AssociationSan Francisco IntersectionDefenseReconstruction911 Call AudioRadio Traffic AudioCNNforensic consultantExemplar Life Sized IntersectionMedicalAssault RifleFieldworkVisibility StudiesNew Forensic TechnologyExplosionConstruction WorkerVideo Capture Frame Ratenorthern california chapterVideo AlignmentConstruction Accidentcrash scene mappingNational NewsLaser ScanMistrialNietoShadowDetermine Degree of ErrorVehicle Crush AnalysisComplete AnalysisLitigation DeclarationsLaser ScanningWire StrikeGuilty Verdict9.75 millionRadiologicalExpert's Analysis.45 CaliberReporter InjuredanimationExpert WitnessPhotometryPersonal InjuryCDAASide BarsPlaintiffForensic Expert Witness AssociationOIS3professionalGunshot Wound ModelingEyeCapital CrimeCrush AnalysisShooter's LocationseachaoMichael BrownCone of UncertaintyDriver's Eye Video3D crime scene mappingCrosswalkBody CameraPhysical EvidenceVariancesNews VanMarco Topete MurderOhio vs TensingAutopsy ReportNighttime Accident Reconstruction3D Gunshot Wound Path ModelForensic AnimationCDAA Winter ConferenceSam DuboseFerguson MOCalifornia District Attorneys Associationhot topicGPS AnalysisCCSFCamera Lense Field of ViewObjectionsforensic mappingExhibits FoundationDetermine Driver's Eye ViewMedical Animation3D Animation and Video CompositingIncident and Exemplar VehiclesError AnalysisCross Examinationconsultant3d VisualizationShootingAccidental ShootingPeer-ReviewedBallistic StudyEye WitnessMonte Carlo MethodBallistic Trajectory AnalysisIllustrate Driver's Eye ViewSpecific CalculationsPower Line Wire Strike3D AnimationLaser Assisted PhotogrammetrySingle Vehicle AccidentTrace back to shooter's locationOfficer Involved ShootingDavid vs. Goliath CaseWitness Testimony3D Laser ScanningCalTransVehicle 3D Laser ScanTrajectory RodsDownstream Benefits of 3D Laser ScanningBus vs. Pedestrian7.6 Mile PursuitForensic Science International7 Days on Witness StandNighttime VideoSeoul KoreaWorld Forensic Festivalby eyefilmFEWASight Obstructions1000 Hours